All resources

    Meeting quality & proof

    How to score a sales meeting: a rubric agencies can actually run

    7 min read

    Most meeting scoring fails for the same reason: the scale is subjective, so the score tells you more about the scorer than the meeting. A 7 out of 10 from an optimistic campaign manager and a 7 from a sceptical client mean different things, which makes the number useless for comparison — and comparison is the entire point.

    The fix is to score observable facts rather than impressions. Below is a rubric built on five components, each scored 0, 1, or 2. Maximum score is 10. Every point has a definition you can check against a transcript.

    The five components

    1. Right person (0–2)

    • 0 — Wrong function, or no influence over the relevant decision.
    • 1 — Relevant function, but confirmed they would need to bring in someone else to proceed.
    • 2 — Holds or directly controls the budget line for this category.

    2. Stated problem (0–2)

    • 0 — No problem described; prospect was listening out of politeness.
    • 1 — A general problem mentioned, without cost, scale, or timeline.
    • 2 — A specific problem with at least one of: a number attached, a deadline, or a named consequence.

    3. Engagement (0–2)

    • 0 — Prospect asked no questions.
    • 1 — Prospect asked clarifying questions about the product.
    • 2 — Prospect asked about implementation, price, timelines, or referenced their own process — signals of someone imagining using it.

    4. Fit against agreed criteria (0–2)

    • 0 — Fails two or more of the campaign's written qualifying criteria.
    • 1 — Fails exactly one.
    • 2 — Meets all of them.

    5. Next step (0–2)

    • 0 — No next step, or 'send me some information'.
    • 1 — A next step agreed in principle, no date.
    • 2 — A specific next step with a date and named attendees.

    Reading the scores

    Treat the total as a band, not a precise value. What you do with a meeting matters more than whether it scored 6 or 7.

    BandReadingAction
    8–10Genuinely qualified. The client should be working this.Hand over and track to outcome.
    5–7Real but incomplete. Usually a targeting or discovery gap.Hand over with a note on what is missing.
    3–4Weak. Would likely be disputed by the client.Review the script and the list before booking more like it.
    0–2Should not have been booked.Do not invoice it. Fix the criteria.

    Where the value actually comes from

    The score itself is not the deliverable. The component breakdown is. A campaign averaging 7 that loses every point on 'next step' has a closing problem on the client's side. A campaign averaging 7 that loses every point on 'right person' has a list problem on yours. Same total, opposite fix — and you can only see the difference if you keep the components separate.

    Run the rubric for a month and the pattern in the components will tell you what to change. That is the part worth the effort.

    See it working

    Prices are fixed and published. No call required to see them.

    See what RevIntel costs