Most meeting scoring fails for the same reason: the scale is subjective, so the score tells you more about the scorer than the meeting. A 7 out of 10 from an optimistic campaign manager and a 7 from a sceptical client mean different things, which makes the number useless for comparison — and comparison is the entire point.
The fix is to score observable facts rather than impressions. Below is a rubric built on five components, each scored 0, 1, or 2. Maximum score is 10. Every point has a definition you can check against a transcript.
The five components
1. Right person (0–2)
- 0 — Wrong function, or no influence over the relevant decision.
- 1 — Relevant function, but confirmed they would need to bring in someone else to proceed.
- 2 — Holds or directly controls the budget line for this category.
2. Stated problem (0–2)
- 0 — No problem described; prospect was listening out of politeness.
- 1 — A general problem mentioned, without cost, scale, or timeline.
- 2 — A specific problem with at least one of: a number attached, a deadline, or a named consequence.
3. Engagement (0–2)
- 0 — Prospect asked no questions.
- 1 — Prospect asked clarifying questions about the product.
- 2 — Prospect asked about implementation, price, timelines, or referenced their own process — signals of someone imagining using it.
4. Fit against agreed criteria (0–2)
- 0 — Fails two or more of the campaign's written qualifying criteria.
- 1 — Fails exactly one.
- 2 — Meets all of them.
5. Next step (0–2)
- 0 — No next step, or 'send me some information'.
- 1 — A next step agreed in principle, no date.
- 2 — A specific next step with a date and named attendees.
Reading the scores
Treat the total as a band, not a precise value. What you do with a meeting matters more than whether it scored 6 or 7.
| Band | Reading | Action |
|---|---|---|
| 8–10 | Genuinely qualified. The client should be working this. | Hand over and track to outcome. |
| 5–7 | Real but incomplete. Usually a targeting or discovery gap. | Hand over with a note on what is missing. |
| 3–4 | Weak. Would likely be disputed by the client. | Review the script and the list before booking more like it. |
| 0–2 | Should not have been booked. | Do not invoice it. Fix the criteria. |
Where the value actually comes from
The score itself is not the deliverable. The component breakdown is. A campaign averaging 7 that loses every point on 'next step' has a closing problem on the client's side. A campaign averaging 7 that loses every point on 'right person' has a list problem on yours. Same total, opposite fix — and you can only see the difference if you keep the components separate.
Run the rubric for a month and the pattern in the components will tell you what to change. That is the part worth the effort.